Crash A Blow To Russian Aerospace Revival
Published: May 12, 2012
The hilltop crash of a Sukhoi passenger jet ferrying journalists and dignitaries on a mission to drum up foreign sales in Indonesia potentially casts a shadow over Kremlin efforts to restore Russia’s once mighty aerospace industry.
It can’t be said how far the loss of the first new passenger jet since the fall of the Soviet Union will damage the rebirth of Russian aviation, but it deals a psychological blow at a time when domestic air safety is also under scrutiny.
The aircraft was on a promotional tour to showcase Russia’s arrival as a peer to regional jet makers such as Brazil’s Embraer and Canada’s Bombardier, with Russia especially anxious to shake off the poor safety reputation of its earlier Soviet domestic fleet.
With so much national pride invested in Russia’s relatively young aircraft project, the crash is likely to shake the confidence of the industry in a way that would be less common among Western firms whose accident rate is statistically lower.
That could change if investigators find no technical fault.
“If it was pilot error then it is not a huge blow to the Russian aerospace industry. However if it was a technical problem with the aircraft, then it could really affect customer perception of the aircraft and order capability,” said Tom Chruszcz of ratings agency Fitch.
President Vladimir Putin, who completed a job swap with former president Dmitry Medvedev to start a new six-year term on Monday, championed the development of Sukhoi’s Superjet regional plane during a previous stint as Russian leader.
Analysts say Putin wants to revive the aerospace sector, shattered by the collapse of the Soviet Union, to demonstrate Moscow’s industrial clout abroad and help project the Kremlin’s authority to voters inside Russia.
Built by the former Soviet Union’s largest warplane maker, Sukhoi’s Superjet is a 78- to 98-seat regional airliner designed for sale to a global market which has historically shied away from Russian-built jets for safety reasons.
Russia has declared ambitions to sell USD$ 250 billion worth of aircraft by 2025 and overtake even Soviet-era output records to compete with Airbus and Boeing.
Sukhoi’s sister company Irkut — both are part of giant state aircraft holding company United Aviation Corporation — has matched China in developing a 150-seat airliner called the MS-21.
Wednesday’s disappearance of a Superjet from Indonesian radars during a demonstration flight near a volcano coincided with a Victory Day military parade on Moscow’s Red Square, where Putin promised to promote Russia on the world stage.
“If this is a catastrophe, then, of course, it’s bad for Russia’s image in the world, given also that last year was unlucky in terms of air safety,” Boris Rybak, director of Moscow think tank Infomost, said, speaking before rescuers located the wreckage and reported no sign of survivors.
FIGHTER FACTORY RESTORED
No industrial effort is more symbolic to Moscow’s push to restore national pride than Sukhoi’s Superjet and its factory.
The eastern city of Komsomolsk-on-Amur in Russia’s Far East was once sealed off from the outside world as a nerve centre of Soviet submarine and fighter production.
But its economy collapsed when orders and government cash dried up at the end of the Cold War and Sukhoi fighter engineers resorted to making children’s bicycles, say local guides.
The Superjet restored jobs and commercial prospects to an abandoned corner of the plant as a jet designed for Westerners slowly took shape beneath peeling Soviet frescoes — yards from the continued trickle of Sukhoi Su-27 combat jet production.
Its long-deserted civil airport terminal, a museum of mosaics and vintage weighing machines, was re-opened to allow investors and foreign media to witness the Superjet’s rollout.
“The Superjet is more than a plane; it is a priority project,” First Deputy Prime Minister Sergei Ivanov told Russian assembly workers at the Superjet’s rollout ceremony in 2007.
Its future now lies in the hands of crash investigators. Moscow will hope the crash does not harm its aerospace sector.
A senior Russian official suggested the crash was caused by pilot error rather than a technical failure, but most safety analysts cautioned it was too early to say what caused the disaster.
The circumstances and potential loss of prestige echo the notorious crash of the Soviet Union’s monster eight-engined Tupolev “Maxim Gorky” during a demonstration flight in 1935. The crash almost 77 years ago to the day was blamed on the pilot, but the exact circumstances have never been fully established.
The reputations of several Western companies are also tied up in the Superjet’s future.
Boeing acted as a consultant on the project including for flight and maintenance crew training. But its role is mainly seen as a symbolic one, with the US group keen to tap into Russian titanium supplies for its next generation of jets.
French and Italian firms have invested heavily and this has been a key selling point in Sukhoi’s marketing efforts.
Alenia Aeronautica, a unit of Italy’s Finmeccanica, bought 25 percent of Sukhoi’s civil division to back the project. It is responsible for the global marketing and after-sales support that are both crucial for winning contracts.
“The Russian aerospace industry collapsed after the Cold War and the Russians aim to work their way back to commercial market acceptance by working with Western suppliers to improve standards, manufacturing procedures and product support,” said analyst Richard Aboulafia of US-based Teal Group.
“This crash doesn’t mean they can’t do it but it is certainly a setback, and it will depend what is found in the investigation. There is a lot we don’t know yet,” he added.
Sukhoi has expressed hopes that the development dollars and technology of Western suppliers would attract Western airlines that may otherwise be reticent about buying Russian. It is also under-cutting rivals with a price of about USD$ 30 million per plane.
So far it has found buyers for 170 aircraft out of 1,000 it would like to sell but no mainstream Western airlines. Irish budget carrier Ryanair has expressed tentative interest.